Sunday, September 16, 2012

Draft of Action Research Summary

I am in EDLD 5397 Internship for Supervision and working on a draft of my Action Research Summary.


How does Middle School Math Success (MS)2 Camp affect student achievement and attitudes towards math in the year following math camp?
The math camp invites only economically disadvantaged students. This goes along with Leander district’s performance goal to, “Reduce the performance gap between economically disadvantaged and non-economically disadvantaged students in Math and Science across all grade levels while continuing to increase the performance of all students as measured by district assessments.” (http://www.leanderisd.org/users/0001/docs/AEIS/1112/DIP1112.pdf)

In the summer of 2011, we started with the original test group of students that attended the first camp for economically disadvantaged students. We gave each of our seven middle schools a list of economically disadvantaged students and asked the teachers to pick students whom they believed would benefit from having a camp in the summer for math. Each campus got to choose the number of students that correlated to the percentage of economically disadvantaged at their campus. During the 2011-2012 school year, I studied the students’ of those that attended the camp by looking at their district assessment scores and comparing the scores to the previous years to see if attending the camp had any impact on their success in math. I looked at the data to see if I could find a correlation. Besides myself, my co-worker, April Chauvette, helped me to gather data and report the findings to the Secondary Math Coordinator, the Director of Curriculum and Instruction and the Executive Director of K-12 Programs to help insure funding for the continuation of the math camp for the summer of 2012.
The information that we had found on attending math camps versus not attending were: Math camp helps to build student’s self esteem towards math and gives them positive experience. Math camp provides opportunity for some one-on-one learning and problem solving in group settings. Math camp also focuses on skills to help students be successful the following year and solidifies the skills taught the previous year. I also saw findings that any kind of academic camp during the summer was better than not attending at all.
After I pulled data for my action research plan, I met with my site supervisor to discuss what the data showed. I was a little disappointed that the data did not show what I thought it would. He said that ‘data is data, it is what it is’. He encouraged me to pull the camp attendees grades from last year and the current school year to see if there was any impact. We also discussed that teachers made the recommendations for the camp for a reason, so the camp attendees might have been low to begin with. Luckily for this past summer, we were able to secure funding, since it was for the best for students and not that the data showed any great improvement from the camp.
I will continue to monitor the new group of camp attendees and their data on district assessments. I will present the data to the Secondary Math Coordinator, the Director of Curriculum and Instruction and the Executive Director of K-12 Programs to try and secure funding for the 2013 summer camp. I do know with the current economic difficulties that the funding might not be there, and since the original data did not show a big difference the camp might be put on the chopping block. 

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Final Reflections


My final reflections over EDLD 5301 Research course started at the beginning of the course with Dr. Arterbury’s lecture making me feel that I could complete the action research because it was attainable. When I got the course title, I got nervous that I wasn’t going to be able to succeed due to my previous experiences with writing research papers. After listening to the first lecture and having Dr. Arterbury and Dr. Jenkins lay the whole course out for us, it was reassuring that I was going to be able to succeed and find the course useful. Throughout the entire five weeks of this course, I enjoyed the lectures and the reassurances they provided.
The Adobe Connect meetings that I got to attend were extremely useful, and I really appreciated the postings of the ones that I was not able to attend. I found that others were having the same questions I was having, and having Dr. Abshire available every week for those meeting times was helpful to be able to answer my most pressing question. I think that these opportunities were very beneficial. I was able to connect with other people in different degree plans and other discussion groups through these meetings. This helped me to get others to follow my blog and find other blogs to follow. I think that helped me understand the research process better.
The discussion boards were also another way I was able to get questions answered throughout the course about assignments or other wonderings I had about my action research plan. I was intrigued by some of the comments from my posts and it helped me to further question things in my research. I hope that this will better my research plan and future research that I want to complete.
In the readings, I really enjoyed the nine passions in the Leading with Passion and Knowledge (Dana, 2009) book. This helped me to see how action research could be used in many different ways in my educational career. It gave me a better understanding of why some things were done in the past, and how I could better improve my presentations of staff development in the future. I also enjoyed Chapter 3 in this book (Dana, 2009) describing all of the different ways to be able to collect data. I had not really considered surveys as a part of my data collection, and them being a valid piece of data for my action research plan. Being able to see the variety of ways to collect data helped me to expand my data collections and hopefully provide better results with my action research plan.
I am not enjoying the tk20 part of this degree. I think it is repetitive, and not necessary. However, I will do what I have to do to obtain my degree.
Lastly, having a blog to post my action research plan and gain feedback from others is a something I fretted over. Now I see the benefit of posting things on the blog for others to see as a way of communicating my action research plan for them to be able to benefit from all the work I am doing. I have been able to get feedback that helped me to see that my data may not show what I wanted it to, and realize that my camp might not be long enough to gain the results I was looking for in the numerical data.
Overall, I have really enjoyed this course and the knowledge it has provided me. I know that I will continue to use action research throughout my educational career, and even into my personal life. 

Dana, N. F. (2009). Leading with Passion and Knowledge. Thousand Oaks: Corwin.

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Updating the Plan

After I pulled data for my action research plan, I met with my site supervisor to discuss what the data showed. I was a little disappointed that the data did not show what I thought it would. He said that ‘data is data, it is what it is’. He encouraged me to pull the camp attendees grades from last year and the current school year to see if there was any impact. We also discussed that teachers made the recommendations for the camp for a reason, so the camp attendees might have been low to begin with. From the comments from the blog and on the discussion board, I think I am also going to look at growth from last year to this year. This does not change my action research plan any, because I am still pulling data-just more data. I will also send out an attitude survey soon to the camp attendees and compare it with the feedback we got at the end of camp. I am hoping that the data will show that the program needs to continue, but I have come to the realization that I may have to recommend that it is discontinued. 

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Action Research Plan


SCHOOL VISION: To close the achievement gap within economically diverse populations.
http://schoolctr.hebisd.edu/education/graphics/trans.gifhttp://schoolctr.hebisd.edu/education/graphics/trans.gif
GOAL:  To continue to be able to offer Middle School Math Success camp to economically disadvantaged students in sixth and seventh grades by offering them a positive math experience and help to prevent the “summer slide”.

OUTCOMES
ACTIVITIES
RESOURCES/ RESEARCH TOOLS NEEDED
RESPONSIBILITY TO ADDRESS ACTIVITIES
TIME LINE
Benchmarks/
ASSESSMENT
Revisions to SIP/PIP based on monitoring and assessments
Math Camp will affect middle school math positively by increasing student achievement and attitude towards math.
Math camp helps to build student’s self esteem towards math and gives them positive experiences. Math camp provides opportunity for some one-on-one learning and problem solving in group settings. Math camp also focuses on skills to help students be successful the following year and solidifies the skills taught the previous year.

List of students eligible for camp, list of students who participated in camp, attitude surveys at the end of camp, district assessment data from fall and spring following camp, additional attitude survey during the school year following camp

Besides myself, my co-worker, April Chauvette, will help me to gather data and report the findings to the Secondary Math Coordinator, the Director of Curriculum and Instruction and the Executive Director of K-12 Programs to help insure funding for the continuation of the math camp.

Timeline: Current to December 2012
I will look at district assessment scores from Fall 2011 and Spring 2012 and compare the data to students who did not attend camp. I will also send out an attitude survey about camp and compare it to the results from the last day of camp.

Follow cohort group to track academic performance on district assessments and attitudes. May need to invite more students to get more participation in the camp. May need to adjust camp materials if proven not successful.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Reflection over Week 2

As I am learning more and more about action research in the educational setting, I am coming to the understanding that to be able to seek change one must research what you think needs to be changed and how others have brought about the change you are wanting. Sometimes, you might find that the change you are seeking is not necessary, or you might find what you think is going well really is not. However, change is necessary to be able to reach all students and not leave any students behind in their learning. All students deserve success, and as an educator, you might need to research best practices to be able to give them the success they deserve.

Wednesday, January 25, 2012

How would educational leaders use blogs?

I think educational leaders can use blogs to help in their action research. They can read other blogs to help find other best practices. Blogs can also be used as the reflective part of the action research, and that could allow others to get a glimpse at what the leaders are thinking.

Using Action Research

Action research or administrator inquiry is a process where one takes a look at a practice and then takes action to make a change on what they learn about their practice. It involves asking questions about the practice, or 'wonderings', then collecting data on those questions. This data is gathered to gain information to be able to analyze the practice. Part of the analysis of the data is to take time to reflect on the data to be able to learn from the experiences of the research. Once you look at the data, then you make a change. You have to start over again to make sure the action you took makes the changes you wanted. It is a continuous cycle. My district calls this PDSA (Plan, Do, Study, Act) or PDSR (Plan, Do, Study, Revise/Revisit). We are always trying to go from good to better than before.
I think I could use action research to look for best practices to help students who do not pass the original EOC exam. It is state law that we provide accelerated instruction for those that do not pass the state assessment. However, the way this instruction is provided is up to the district. I have been involved with the accelerated instruction for 8th graders who did not pass TAKS for the past several years, and I think we developed a good process. I would like to take what we learned is successful from that and apply it to the EOC accelerated instruction.